Shelter Island Slice Menu (Update 2025)

Shelter Island Slice, located at 3 N Ferry Rd in Shelter Island, NY, is a beer bar offering a variety of pizzas, sandwiches, and pasta dishes. With options for delivery, takeout, outdoor seating, and accommodating groups, this spot is a go-to for many customers. Reviews rave about the delicious food, friendly staff, and overall welcoming atmosphere. Highlights include the buffalo chicken slice, pepperoni slice, chicken bacon ranch slice, and their signature Penne a la Mimo pasta dish. The restaurant also offers a range of options for pizza lovers, with favorites like the sausage-loaded pie standing out. Whether you're a local or just passing through on a ferry, Shelter Island Slice offers a tasty and affordable dining experience. The combination of great food, excellent service, and cozy ambiance make this spot a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.